Dear Company Spokesperson,
Thank you so much for your response to the inquiry as to whether or not the ingredients in your product contain corn.
I have to point out, however, that you were not being asked to comment on the safety of corn derivatives for individuals with corn allergies. Nor are you being asked to replace the role of medical advisor. And if I took your advice to discuss every product I was considering placing across my lips with my medical provider, my medical provider would not have time to attend to any other patients. That's why they suggest I do my own research. As they advise every patient to do.
Which is why you received a letter inquiring as to the origination of your ingredients.
I'm pleased to hear that you know of no documented reactions to caramel color/citric acid/microcrystalline cellulose etc. Unfortunately, I have experienced reactions under blind trial conditions. These reactions were identified through the use of food diaries and helpful companies who were willing to share the source of their ingredients. How else would I know why ascorbic from batch A made me sick and ascorbic acid from batch B didn't?
I believe my doctor's response was "Huh, that's weird. There are no documented cases of allergic reactions to these derivatives. But if they affect you like this, I think you should definitely avoid them."
Which brings me full circle to the problem at hand.
Where were your ingredients derived? I am asking for my health, not for the heck of it. I'm not asking for proprietary information. I'm asking for sources of ingredients listed in your product.
If you don't want my business, simply respond that you don't serve people with unique allergies. Don't quote the FDA's impressive quality control measures. I presume, since you are still in business, that you adhere to their policies. I don't really care about FAAN's policies since the top 8 allergens, as identified by the FDA, don't really pertain to corn. But I do think that as a consumer, I have the right to know where products come from. What country. What plant. And whether the plant originated as a seedling or a science fiction worthy science experiment.
Thank you.
This letter was inspired by THIS post at Delphi forums.
Welcome to my un-corny life...a series of vignettes interspersed among real food allergy (intolerance?) discussion.
Showing posts with label form letter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label form letter. Show all posts
Sunday, July 18, 2010
Labels:
allergy,
Corn,
form letter,
frustration,
label,
vent
Saturday, June 26, 2010
Form Letters
Recently a form letter response was posted on one of my forums and I have a few thoughts to share on the subject.
More and more companies are developing formulaic answers to allergy questions. The problem is that there are more than just 8 allergens in the world. And even within those allergens, there is a wide variety of acceptable risk. Until relatively recently, companies who cared could be depended on to respond with a thoughtful, researched response. Other companies could be ferreted out by their lack of response and amusing replies (Such as my favorite: "I can't imagine why there'd be corn in cheese. Where do you buy your cheese?")
Anyways. Here is a typical form letter response from a big box company:
Thank you for taking the time to contact us regarding {product name}. We strive to maintain the highest quality products and appreciate your patronage.
(Company name} labeling declares major allergens (peanuts, soybeans, milk, eggs, fish, crustaceans, tree nuts, and wheat) and we follow the U.S. FDA's regulations. We recognize the serious nature of the allergen issue and we strive to minimize risk.
Both major and minor ingredients of all products, as well as all processing procedures and equipment, are closely scrutinized and all potential allergen issues ... are declared on our labeling.
If a product contains gluten (ie. wheat, oats, barley, etc...) as a major component, we will include it in the ingredient list. For consumers concerned about the presence of trace amounts of gluten, we suggest avoiding products that include natural flavors or spices.
We assure you that strict manufacturing processes and procedures are in place and that all of our manufacturing facilities follow rigid allergen control programs that include staff training, segregation of allergen ingredients, production scheduling, and thorough cleaning and sanitation.
Thank you for your continued support. If we can be of further assistance, please feel free to contact us {Contact info} Sincerely, Company representative
Now, at first glance, this letter seems very helpful. It's well written, professional, and addresses both allergies and gluten. They state that strict manufacturing processes are in place, reassuring the reader that quality and safety are paramount.
Now take a second glance. Note that only the top 8 allergens are addressed, "All potential allergen issues are declared..." This means that they decide, within the guidelines drawn by FDA and FAAN, what exactly is an allergy issue. Without consulting you, or your doctor.
Note also that specific manufacturing processes are not addressed. Is the facility dedicated allergen free? Are there open vats of certain allergens? What are the rigid allergen control programs?
While I have no doubt they are thorough, and present no problem to the average allergic individual, this letter does not specifically address any specific concerns. It's no better than a simple FAQ posted on a website.
As an allergy sufferer, it's my job to weigh my risk benefit ratio in any individual food. I don't have the convenience of farmland, or the money to create a self sustaining agricultural space. This means I do need to rely upon the grocery store to provide my daily caloric needs. Which, in turn, means that I need various companies to give me quality information on their products. I need to know where corn, or gluten, or dairy, or any other specific ingredient, might be in those products. I need to know where certain ingredients are derived. I may need more information on packaging protocols.
And I need my questions to be taken seriously, and answered by an individual who thinks for themselves, not a machine or someone clicking buttons that have been approved by the PR department.
For those new to the world of food allergies responses like the above can be downright dangerous. They give a false sense of security, and although they end with an entreaty to contact the company if there are further questions, they also give the individual a feeling that their answer should have been answered. After all, the company has mysterious, but strict, manufacturing processes. They train their employees. They scrutinize for allergens. And who better to recognize a specific allergen...the individual avoiding it,or the company cooking for a nation of buyers?
Right. The real answer isn't quite the one given.
For those who are new to the world of food allergies, don't be discouraged by canned answers. Ask, and keep asking. Some answers can be found in FAQ and form letters, but many more require an individual answer. And if your allergen isn't found on the top 8, you may need a direct response from someone who works with the product, not just someone in the office.
More and more companies are developing formulaic answers to allergy questions. The problem is that there are more than just 8 allergens in the world. And even within those allergens, there is a wide variety of acceptable risk. Until relatively recently, companies who cared could be depended on to respond with a thoughtful, researched response. Other companies could be ferreted out by their lack of response and amusing replies (Such as my favorite: "I can't imagine why there'd be corn in cheese. Where do you buy your cheese?")
Anyways. Here is a typical form letter response from a big box company:
Thank you for taking the time to contact us regarding {product name}. We strive to maintain the highest quality products and appreciate your patronage.
(Company name} labeling declares major allergens (peanuts, soybeans, milk, eggs, fish, crustaceans, tree nuts, and wheat) and we follow the U.S. FDA's regulations. We recognize the serious nature of the allergen issue and we strive to minimize risk.
Both major and minor ingredients of all products, as well as all processing procedures and equipment, are closely scrutinized and all potential allergen issues ... are declared on our labeling.
If a product contains gluten (ie. wheat, oats, barley, etc...) as a major component, we will include it in the ingredient list. For consumers concerned about the presence of trace amounts of gluten, we suggest avoiding products that include natural flavors or spices.
We assure you that strict manufacturing processes and procedures are in place and that all of our manufacturing facilities follow rigid allergen control programs that include staff training, segregation of allergen ingredients, production scheduling, and thorough cleaning and sanitation.
Thank you for your continued support. If we can be of further assistance, please feel free to contact us {Contact info} Sincerely, Company representative
Now, at first glance, this letter seems very helpful. It's well written, professional, and addresses both allergies and gluten. They state that strict manufacturing processes are in place, reassuring the reader that quality and safety are paramount.
Now take a second glance. Note that only the top 8 allergens are addressed, "All potential allergen issues are declared..." This means that they decide, within the guidelines drawn by FDA and FAAN, what exactly is an allergy issue. Without consulting you, or your doctor.
Note also that specific manufacturing processes are not addressed. Is the facility dedicated allergen free? Are there open vats of certain allergens? What are the rigid allergen control programs?
While I have no doubt they are thorough, and present no problem to the average allergic individual, this letter does not specifically address any specific concerns. It's no better than a simple FAQ posted on a website.
As an allergy sufferer, it's my job to weigh my risk benefit ratio in any individual food. I don't have the convenience of farmland, or the money to create a self sustaining agricultural space. This means I do need to rely upon the grocery store to provide my daily caloric needs. Which, in turn, means that I need various companies to give me quality information on their products. I need to know where corn, or gluten, or dairy, or any other specific ingredient, might be in those products. I need to know where certain ingredients are derived. I may need more information on packaging protocols.
And I need my questions to be taken seriously, and answered by an individual who thinks for themselves, not a machine or someone clicking buttons that have been approved by the PR department.
For those new to the world of food allergies responses like the above can be downright dangerous. They give a false sense of security, and although they end with an entreaty to contact the company if there are further questions, they also give the individual a feeling that their answer should have been answered. After all, the company has mysterious, but strict, manufacturing processes. They train their employees. They scrutinize for allergens. And who better to recognize a specific allergen...the individual avoiding it,or the company cooking for a nation of buyers?
Right. The real answer isn't quite the one given.
For those who are new to the world of food allergies, don't be discouraged by canned answers. Ask, and keep asking. Some answers can be found in FAQ and form letters, but many more require an individual answer. And if your allergen isn't found on the top 8, you may need a direct response from someone who works with the product, not just someone in the office.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)